Mortgages & PropertyShared Ownership vs Help to Buy UK — Which Is Better?
Comparing Shared Ownership and Help to Buy schemes. How each works, costs, pros and cons, and which suits your situation.
Both schemes help first-time buyers, but they work very differently.
Quick Comparison
| Feature | Shared Ownership | Help to Buy (Equity Loan)* |
|---|
| How it works | Buy share, rent rest | Government loan |
| Still available | Yes | England: Closed March 2023 |
| Deposit | 5-10% of your share | 5% of property |
| Monthly payments | Mortgage + rent | Mortgage + loan repayment later |
| Own eventually | Staircase to 100% | Full ownership from start |
*Help to Buy Equity Loan closed to new applications in England March 2023. Different schemes exist in Wales/Scotland.
Shared Ownership Explained
How It Works
| Step | Details |
|---|
| Buy a share | Usually 25-75% |
| Rent the rest | From housing association |
| Deposit needed | 5-10% of your share |
| Mortgage | On your share only |
| Service charge | Usually applies |
Example Numbers
| Property value | £300,000 |
|---|
| Your share (40%) | £120,000 |
| Deposit (10% of share) | £12,000 |
| Mortgage needed | £108,000 |
| Rent on remaining 60% | ~£450/month |
| Mortgage payment (approx) | ~£600/month |
| Total monthly | ~£1,050 |
Staircasing
| What | Buying more shares |
|---|
| When | Anytime after purchase |
| How | Buy extra % at current value |
| Goal | Eventually own 100% |
| Rent reduces | As share increases |
| Costs | Valuation, legal fees each time |
Buying More Shares
| Current Share | Buy Extra | New Share |
|---|
| 40% | 10% | 50% |
| 50% | 25% | 75% |
| 75% | 25% | 100% (full owner) |
Help to Buy Equity Loan (England — Now Closed)
How It Worked
| Feature | Details |
|---|
| Government loan | 20% (40% in London) |
| Your deposit | 5% |
| Mortgage | 75% (55% in London) |
| Interest-free | First 5 years |
| Then | Interest charges apply |
| Repay | When sell or end of mortgage |
Key Point
| Status | Closed to new applications |
|---|
| England | March 2023 |
| Existing loans | Continue as agreed |
| Alternatives | See below |
Wales and Scotland
Wales Help to Buy
| Feature | Details |
|---|
| Status | Check gov.wales for current availability |
| How works | Similar equity loan model |
| Eligibility | New-build, price caps |
Scotland
| Schemes | Status |
|---|
| First Home Fund | Was available (check current status) |
| Other initiatives | LIFT schemes |
| Check | mygov.scot for current options |
Alternatives Now Available
First Homes (England)
| Feature | Details |
|---|
| What | Discount market sale |
| Discount | 30-50% off market value |
| Eligibility | First-time buyers |
| Price cap | After discount |
| Restriction | Discount stays with property |
Lifetime ISA
| Feature | Details |
|---|
| Bonus | 25% on up to £4,000/year |
| Max bonus | £1,000/year |
| Must be | Under 40 to open |
| For | Property under £450,000 |
Mortgage Guarantee Scheme
| Feature | Details |
|---|
| What | Government backs 95% mortgages |
| Benefit | More lenders offer them |
| You provide | 5% deposit |
| Normal mortgage | Standard product |
Shared Ownership: Pros and Cons
Advantages
| Pro | Details |
|---|
| Lower deposit | 5-10% of share only |
| Smaller mortgage | Easier to get |
| Get on ladder | On lower income |
| Staircase option | Buy more when can afford |
| Still available | Application open |
Disadvantages
| Con | Details |
|---|
| Pay rent + mortgage | Never rent-free until 100% |
| Rent can increase | Usually capped |
| Service charges | Often apply |
| Selling restrictions | Housing association rights |
| May be harder to sell | Niche market |
| Can’t always improve | Need permission |
| Leasehold usually | Not freehold |
Help to Buy: Pros and Cons (For Existing Users)
Advantages
| Pro | Details |
|---|
| Full ownership | From day one |
| Interest-free period | First 5 years |
| Only 5% deposit | Government provided 20%+ |
| Normal sale | When selling |
Disadvantages
| Con | Details |
|---|
| New-build only | Often premium priced |
| Must repay loan | % of future value |
| Interest starts year 6 | Adds to costs |
| If value rises | Repay more |
| Regional price caps | Applied |
Which Suits Your Situation?
Choose Shared Ownership If
| Situation | Why |
|---|
| Can’t save large deposit | Lower entry point |
| Income below thresholds | Still possible |
| Happy to staircase | Long-term plan |
| Comfortable with rent | Ongoing cost |
| Only option available | Help to Buy closed |
Alternatives to Consider
| If | Consider |
|---|
| Help to Buy no longer available | First Homes, LISA |
| Want full ownership | Save for 5%+ deposit |
| Prices too high | Consider different area |
| Not sure about buying | Rent and save |
Costs Comparison
Upfront Costs
| Cost | Shared Ownership | Standard Purchase |
|---|
| Deposit | 5-10% of share | 5-20% of property |
| Legal fees | Yes | Yes |
| Survey | Yes | Yes |
| Stamp Duty | On your share (exemptions may apply) | Standard |
Ongoing Costs
| Cost | Shared Ownership | Full Ownership |
|---|
| Mortgage | On your share | On full property |
| Rent | On remaining share | None |
| Service charge | Usually | Depends |
| Ground rent | If leasehold | If leasehold |
| Maintenance | Usually in service charge | Your responsibility |
Summary: Shared Ownership Decision
Key Facts
| Shared Ownership | Details |
|---|
| Buy | 25-75% share |
| Rent | Remaining share |
| Deposit | 5-10% of your share |
| Staircase | To 100% over time |
| Restrictions | Some apply |
Is It Right For You?
| Question | Yes/No |
|---|
| Can you afford rent + mortgage? | |
| Happy with potential restrictions? | |
| Plan to staircase eventually? | |
| Understand leasehold implications? | |
| Comfortable with selling process? | |
Alternatives to Explore
| Option | Best For |
|---|
| First Homes | Discount on new-build |
| Lifetime ISA | Saving for deposit |
| Standard mortgage | If can afford 5%+ |
| Mortgage guarantee scheme | 95% LTV |
| Rent longer and save | Larger deposit |
Key Resources
| Resource | For |
|---|
| ownyourhome.gov.uk | Shared Ownership |
| gov.uk/first-homes | First Homes |
| gov.uk/lifetime-isa | LISA |
| Local housing associations | Available properties |
Help to Buy in England has ended, but Shared Ownership remains a genuine route to home ownership for those with limited deposits. Understand the ongoing costs and restrictions before committing. If Shared Ownership doesn’t suit you, explore the alternatives — there are still options for first-time buyers to get on the property ladder.
Your home may be repossessed if you do not keep up repayments on your mortgage. PocketWise provides information and guidance — we do not offer financial advice. Seek independent mortgage advice before making decisions about borrowing.
You Might Also Find Useful